Brakes, rotors, or something else?

Hello – my brake pad warning lights get just came on. Every time I go to the dealership they tell me I need pads and rotors – are they ripping me off? The last few times the sensor hadn't even gone off yet and they insisted I needed both done. But how is it possible I need to change the rotors too?

My car has 100000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Experienced mechanics share their insights in answering this question :
Hello There,
Generally, the rotors should not need to be replaced very often unless they become warped due to excessive heat which will eventually cause a vibrating or shaking sensation when you press the brakes. This is caused by low spots in the rotors causing the pads to be pressed against an uneven surface which is what generates the vibrating effect. The brake reservoir has a sensor inside that detects when the brake fluid reaches a certain point which generally indicates that it is time to replace the pads. As your pads wear thinner and thinner over time, the brake lines require more and more brake fluid to maintain the same amount of hydraulic pressure in the brake lines. As a result, the brake fluid level sensor will trigger a warning light indicating that the brake fluid level is low. I would recommend having an expert from YourMechanic come to your location to diagnose your braking system to determine what may be causing this light to come on.

How to Identify and Fix Common car Problems ?

Our sources include academic articles, blog posts, and personal essays from experienced mechanics :

Audi ceramic brakes offer excellent stopping power and also have better fade resistance than traditional brakes, while weighing less. The brakes are made out of carbon fiber reinforced ceramic, a very strong, hard, and wear-resistant material.
The brake pads make contact with the warped rotors. Your steering wheel vibrates — the sensation is also described as shuddering or pulsing — because the pads are following the contours of the warped rotors. If your steering wheel is giving you vigorous handshakes, a rotor replacement may be in order.
We have a large range of MTEC performance brake discs and MTEC brake pads. We also stock Mintex, EBC, Brembo and Carbotech Brake Pads. We have recently added our new range of high quality braided brake hoses.
Ordinarily, Audi Q5 rotors need to be replaced every 30,000 – 80,000 miles depending on the factors above.
Genuine Audi brake pads are designed specifically for your Audi and are built on the highest standards just like the artistic brake pads that were installed on your vehicle when leaving the factory. It`s persuasive to use Audi artistic manufactured parts on your vehicle.
If your vehicle uses disc brakes, the rotors are the discs themselves. The rotors are located on the inside of each of your wheels, and the spin at the same pace as your wheels. When you press down on the brakes, your pads will squeeze around the rotors, helping your vehicle stop.
Your vehicle has one of two brake systems, discs, or drums. Discs are also known as rotors. Drums are typically found on older vehicles, although some newer vehicles feature disc brakes on the front and drums on the rear.
If you`re looking for a more eye-catching, higher performance disc for your Audi A2 (8Z0), then Brembo cross-drilled discs are the perfect choice. As well as making your car stand out from the crowd with their stylish looks, Brembo Xtra discs boast potent, effective braking performance in all conditions.
Audi Brake rotor replacement can cost anywhere between $300 – $750 for each four rotors to be replaced. This rate estimate includes labor and parts.
Traditional hydraulic brakes are the most common type of brake system found in BMWs. They work by using brake fluid to transfer pressure from the brake pedal to the brake pads, which then clamp down on the brake rotor to slow or stop the vehicle.
Not only the Formula 1 single-seaters bearing the brand of the manufacturer from Maranello use Brembo brakes, but also the cars that compete in the GT championships, as well as those racing in the three Ferrari Challenge events: Europe, North America and Asia-Pacific.
If you`re looking for a more eye-catching, higher performance disc for your Audi A2 (8Z0), then Brembo cross-drilled discs are the perfect choice. As well as making your car stand out from the crowd with their stylish looks, Brembo Xtra discs boast potent, effective braking performance in all conditions.
Not only the Formula 1 single-seaters bearing the brand of the manufacturer from Maranello use Brembo brakes, but also the cars that compete in the GT championships, as well as those racing in the three Ferrari Challenge events: Europe, North America and Asia-Pacific.
Actually, most of the Lamborghini lineup comes with carbon-ceramic brakes on both the front and the rear. This even includes the new Lamborghini Urus. The only current Lamborghini models that do not use carbon-ceramic brakes are the RWD Huracan models which use ventilated steel disc brakes.

Relevant Questions and Answers :

the most relevant questions and answers related to your specific issue

EPC light on 2004 Jetta. Code said brake switch faulty, but brakes lights worked. Replaced brake switch, now no brake lights.
ANSWER : Hi there. The first thing that pops in my mind beyond of what you have listed is perhaps the electrical harness attached to the brake switch. Perhaps the harness itself is damaged or you have an exposed wire, loose ground wire somewhere. You might want to have a professional mobile mechanic come to your location and complete a brake lights not working inspection to help you diagnose this issue.

Low brake pedal and anti-lock brakes are not kicking in.
ANSWER : The brake pedal is working to stop the vehicle, but there may be air in the controller unit causing the ABS brakes to not function. I recommend bleeding the brake system from the farthest location from the master cylinder to the master cylinder including the ABS unit. If the brakes are still spongy after a full bleed, then the controller will need to be replaced. If you need further assistance with your brake pedal being spongy, then seek out a professional, such as one from Your Mechanic, to help you.

Uneven brake rotor wear
ANSWER : Hello. I tried to view the pictures but the link seems to be broken. It sounds like you have two different problems reading the description of the problem. The first is the brake pads being too tight and binding in the caliper bracket. This is most likely caused from the pad ends are not machined smooth and do not slide into the caliper bracket smooth. This will cause them to bind and cause low brake application or will keep the brakes partly applied wearing them down quickly. The other possible problem is the caliper may be binding on the slides or the piston is binding. If you would like precise advise on exactly what needs repair, have a certified professional diagnose the brake system in person and follow through with correct repairs.

When I put my foot on the brake my back left brake light goes off, when I take it off the brake the brake light comes on
ANSWER : I would suggest trying to disconnect and reconnect the wiring to the rear lights. I have seen these older Toyota vehicles rear lighting short out on the lights themselves due to the way the light circuit was made on the lamp housing. Look at the housing circuit on the light to see if one is touching another, and that could tell you why it is malfunctioning. There could also be a problem with the brake light switch. If you are not comfortable dealing with wires, I recommend getting in touch with a certified mechanic who can look at your brake light issue for you to see what’s going on.

Brake rotor burned after brakes replacement
ANSWER : It sounds like the parking brake mechanism has failed and kept the brakes on in that wheel. I cannot say if the dealer should have found the problem at that time, since the problem may not have been there at the time they did the brake service for you.

If you feel they did not fix it correctly, then take it up with the manager to see what can be done to help pay for the repairs. The problem was not there before they touched the vehicle and now it is. Maybe something they did or didn’t do would require an investigation by an independent shop.

Brakes, rotors, or something else?
ANSWER : This is a common symptom of a wheel bearing(s) failing. A wheel bearing will usually fail due to pitting or small damage on the surface of the rollers or the bearing race. Both the surface of the rollers and the race is precision machined to tight tolerances and highly polished to allow the rollers to pass easily over the race with the addition of bearing grease for lubrication and cooling. Over time the bearing will wear slightly, allowing microscopic pieces of metal into the grease. Bearing noise can sound a lot like a brake pad dragging or grinding. It can also sound like whirring, whining or humming depending on how much sound deadening material your vehicle has in it. Bearing noise will always be dependent on vehicle speed meaning as you speed up or slow down the noise should change frequency or loudness. Cornering may affect the noise from a damaged front wheel bearing and is usually more pronounced as you make turns. I would suggest having a professional from Your Mechanic come to your home to take a look at the car and check your wheel bearings for failure.

Supportive bar attached to brake pedal interrupts proper braking process
ANSWER : It’s possible to have someone alter the brake pedal or adapt a brake pedal from a different vehicle. You may call around to some customization shops to see if anyone is interested in taking on the project. But first, I would try reaching out to the selling dealer with your concern – especially since it is a new model. Good luck.

Front steering/suspension shaking while braking
ANSWER : Hello. It is possible that you could have a control arm bushing that has failed. When a control arm bushing fails and the brakes are applied, the vehicle will display these exact same symptoms that you described. I would recommend enlisting the assistance of a qualified professional to inspect your steering and suspension parts for worn control arm bushings. If any excessive wear is found in the control arm bushings, I would recommend having them replaced as soon as possible because this can result in a safety issue. If you need help getting this taken care of, a certified professional can diagnose the suspension and brake system to verify the problem and move forward with appropriate repairs.